UX Improvements for Jupyter Chat Interface

[ellisonbg]

UX Improvements for Jupyter Chat Interface

Summary

This PR introduces a comprehensive set of user experience improvements to the Jupyter Chat interface, focusing on visual clarity, usability, and modernization. The changes streamline the chat interaction patterns, reduce visual clutter, and create a more polished, professional appearance throughout the application.

Screenshots

Screenshot 1: Clean Input State

What you're seeing: The new empty chat interface with the modernized input field. Notice:

• Clean, minimalist placeholder text: "Enter a chat message, @ to mention..."
• New square send button with upward arrow icon in the bottom-right corner (currently disabled/grayed out since there's no text)
• Removed the old attachment button and verbose button designs
• No top border on the input area, creating a cleaner visual flow

Screenshot 2: Code Blocks and Message Display (Full View)

What you're seeing: A complete conversation showing multiple UI improvements:

• User message bubble (top) shows the asymmetric design - your own messages appear without redundant headers or avatars
• AI response (Jupyternaut) shows clean formatting with the avatar and timestamp on the left
• Code block toolbar at the bottom-right of the code snippet demonstrates the new borderless design - notice there's no border above the toolbar icons (copy, insert above, insert below, replace cell buttons)
• The input field at bottom shows the same clean design with the square send button

Screenshot 3: Attachment Preview (Input with File)

What you're seeing: The new attachment chip design in the input field:

• Modern chip-style attachment showing "README.md" with a clean bordered design
• Small "X" close button on the right side of the attachment chip for easy removal
• The attachment has subtle background color and border styling
• Blue square send button is now enabled (colored blue) since there's content to send
• The attachment preview is integrated cleanly into the input area above the text field

Screenshot 4: Full Conversation with Attachment

What you're seeing: A complete view showing:

• User's message bubble at the top displaying the question along with the attachment chip inline - the "README.md" file appears as a clean, bordered chip within the message
• AI's detailed response from Jupyternaut below
• The scroll indicator button in the bottom-right (circular button with down arrow) for navigating long conversations
• Input field at the bottom showing the consistent clean design

Screenshot 5: Sidebar Chat View

What you're seeing: The chat interface in sidebar mode (narrower layout):

• Demonstrates how the responsive design adapts to constrained spaces
• Same clean message bubbles and code formatting work well in the sidebar
• The layout intelligently adjusts spacing and sizing for the sidebar context
• All UI improvements (code toolbar, message formatting, input design) remain consistent

---

Motivation & UX Benefits

1. Modernized Chat Input Design

The chat input has been completely redesigned with a focus on clarity and modern UX patterns:

• Square send button with arrow icon: Follows modern messaging app conventions (similar to iMessage, WhatsApp, Slack), making the primary action immediately recognizable. The button is:
  • Grayed out/disabled when there's no content
  • Blue and enabled when there's text or attachments to send
• Simplified button design: Replaced verbose buttons with clean icon buttons, reducing visual noise
• Removed top border: Eliminated the border separating the input from the message area for a cleaner, more integrated feel
• Better placeholder text: Clear instruction to "Enter a chat message, @ to mention..." guides users

2. Enhanced Attachment Experience

Attachments received significant UX improvements to make them more useful and visually appealing:

• Modern chip-style design: Attachments now appear as clean, bordered chips with subtle background colors
• Better visual hierarchy: Clear distinction between the filename and the close button
• Improved remove functionality: Small, unobtrusive "X" button with hover states for easy removal
• Inline display: Attachments appear both in the input area (before sending) and within sent messages as integrated chips
• Tooltips: Full file paths shown on hover to help users understand what's attached

3. Cleaner Code Block Toolbar

• Removed redundant border: Eliminated the border above code toolbars which created unnecessary visual separation and clutter
• Consistent button styling: All toolbar buttons (copy, insert above, insert below, replace cell) use consistent icon button patterns
• Better visual feedback: Improved hover and disabled states make button availability clearer

4. Improved Message Display

• Asymmetric message headers: Your own messages no longer show redundant headers or avatars, creating a cleaner conversation flow similar to modern chat apps (iMessage, WhatsApp, Slack)
• AI messages show full context: Messages from AI assistants (like Jupyternaut) include avatar and timestamp for clarity
• Better visual hierarchy: Reduced clutter helps users focus on the actual content of conversations
• Flexible layout: Support for different chat areas (main vs. sidebar) with appropriate spacing

5. Better Autocomplete Experience

Multiple improvements to the @ mention autocomplete functionality:

• Simplified styling: Cleaner, more focused autocomplete dropdown
• Fixed Enter key behavior: Pressing Enter now properly selects autocomplete items instead of submitting incomplete input
• Multiple mentions support: Users can now use @ mentions anywhere in their message, not just at the start
• Improved focus management: Better keyboard navigation and selection behavior

6. Responsive Design

• Sidebar optimization: The chat interface works beautifully in both full-width and sidebar layouts
• Adaptive spacing: Appropriate padding and margins adjust based on the chat area
• Consistent experience: All improvements work seamlessly across different layout contexts

Technical Changes

• Replaced custom tooltip button components with standard MUI Tooltip + IconButton/Button patterns
• Modernized button styling using MUI sx prop with CSS variables for theme consistency
• Added ChatArea type to track whether chat is in main area or sidebar
• Improved focus and keyboard navigation throughout the input system
• Enhanced attachment rendering with chip-style design
• Streamlined CSS by moving inline and reducing custom classes
• Removed custom MUI wrapper components (TooltippedButton, TooltippedIconButton, ContrastingTooltip)
• Removed 58 lines from input.css and significantly simplified chat.css

Files Changed

• 32 files changed: 814 insertions(+), 961 deletions(-)
• Major refactoring of button components and styling
• Simplified CSS architecture with better use of MUI theming

Accessibility Improvements

• All buttons now have proper aria-label attributes
• Tooltips provide context for icon-only buttons
• Better keyboard navigation support
• Clearer disabled states for better understanding of available actions
• Improved contrast and visual feedback

Future Work

• Message editing functionality is currently disabled (commented out) due to broken behavior and will be fixed in a follow-up PR
• Stop button functionality is stubbed out and needs backend integration to halt AI response generation

[github-actions]

👈 Launch a Binder on branch ellisonbg/jupyter-chat/ux-improvements

[ellisonbg]

Are there instructions on how to update all the UI tests with new screenshots? I am guessing that ~all need to be updated.

[dlqqq]

@ellisonbg The snapshots can be updated by posting a GitHub comment. Most of the failing tests are not snapshot tests however, so they will require fixing. Looking into this now.

[dlqqq]

Just fixed 2 major issues caught by the E2E tests:

1. Chat input was being cleared on blur, i.e. clicking out of the chat input would clear its content.
2. The send button was not sending the message on click.

Just pushed these changes & will continue iterating on the updated test report.

[dlqqq]

Made some minor updates to attempt fixing every failing E2E test based on the most recent report.

• Added back classnames being used for E2E tests.
• Removed message edition tests since we agreed to rework message edition.
• Removed raw time tests as they seem unnecessary.
• Updated various assertions in failing E2E tests to reflect latest UI state.

[dlqqq]

bot please update snapshots

[nakul-py]

@dlqqq UI tests seems to be fixed.

[nakul-py]

I apologies but can i also work on the fixing the UI tests?

[nakul-py]

Hurray! @dlqqq adee583 fixes all the ui tests errors

[dlqqq]

@nakul-py Thanks for offering anyways. We need this merged so we can show it off in our Jupyter AI talk at Jupytercon 2025 next week. Maybe you can help us next time 🤗

[nakul-py]

Yes @dlqqq My pleasure is to help you guys anytime.
Happy JupyterCon to all of you guys ;)

[SylvainCorlay]

As discussed with @brichet, we should merge this and tag an alpha shortly after.
If any follow up work or fixes are required, we will do so after the alpha.