This project aims to compare the transmission quality of file transfer via different protocols: OPC UA (with FileType), HTTP, and FTP. The comparison is made using a client-server model, where the client retrieves a file from the server using each of the protocols.
This project provides a detailed comparison of file transfer protocols. It measures the performance and reliability of OPC UA, HTTP, and FTP in transferring files from a server to a client. The comparison is done under various network conditions to provide a comprehensive analysis. More details will be provided soon.
The project requires installations on both the client and server sides. It is recommended to use two separate computers or a network simulation for more accurate results.
On the client side, you need to install some Python packages for the main script. You can do this by running the following command:
pip install -r requirements.txtOn the server side, you need to install an HTTP server, FTP server, and an OPC UA server. You can adapt the main.py script to match the path or nodeId of your server.
In this example, the following server applications and configurations are used:
For the HTTP server, we use the Apache2 server as part of the XAMPP application.
For the FTP server, we use the VSFTP server as a Docker container, specifically delfer/alpine-ftp-server.
see sample node js server (opcua-file-server)(opcua-file-server/README.md)
- Copy the test file to the different servers.
- Open the
main.pyfile and modify the configuration (URL, password, etc.). - Modify the
opcua_downloadmethod in themain.pyfile to match your server.
If you're using the custom Node.js OPC UA server, you don't need to change the opcua_download method. However, you will need to replace the manifest.txt file with your test.data file.
- Add SMB as a protocol.
- Implement security measures.
- Add network simulation (like Mininet).